More from Top10.co.uk

BT fibre optic broadband vs. Virgin Media fibre optic broadband - is it war?

Posted 25th January 2010 at 4:31pm by Jonathan Leggett

john  user icon

BT’s new super fast broadband service has set the scene for a fibre optic face-off with Virgin Media.

BT has ignited a war of words between rival broadband provider Virgin Media after launching a new super fast home broadband service in direct competition with Virgin Media’s offering.

Since late 2008, Virgin Media has been the UK’s only fibre optic broadband provider, thanks to heavy investment in a next generation network. Adoption of this technology enabled the company to offer consumers a connection speed of up to 50Mb to those who signed up to its high-end XXL package.

BT Virgin duel

However, last week BT announced a rival fibre optic home broadband service, dubbed BT Infinity. Priced from £19.99 per month, Infinity subscribers can access internet connection speeds of up to 40Mb. This will be available to four million homes by the end of December 2010.

According to BT, those who choose the lower cost Option 1 package can also expect upsteam speeds of up to 2Mb and are subject to a 20Gb monthly usage limit. Meanwhile, Option 2 customers are in line for a maximum upstream speed of 10Mb and unlimited monthly downloads for £24.99. Both products offer download speeds of up to 40Mb.

Alongside its announcement, BT made much of its forthcoming additions of its product portfolio’s pricing in comparison to Virgin Media’s existing super fast broadband deals. In particular, the broadband supplier noted that Infinity Option 1 is £7.47 per month cheaper than Virgin Media’s flagship XXL broadband package.

BT also highlighted that the maximum upstream speed of up to 10Mb with Infinity Option 2 is the fastest in the UK and is over six times faster than Virgin Media’s fastest service. This means that BT customers can expect much greater interactivity, BT claims.

The announcement has prompted a hard-hitting response from Virgin Media. Chief among its counterpoints are that although BT’s service uses VDSL technology the “last stretch” to their customers’ home is copper wire. This means that “unlike Virgin Media, their broadband will still be affected by distance” with the result that “many BT customers will not get the speeds they expect”.

BT’s claims that its service represents better value was also attacked. According to Virgin Media, the lower headline price of Infinity Option 1 is illusory because of the 20GB monthly download limit that BT applies. This is enough to download just four High Definition movies per month, Virgin Media calculates.

Virgin Media further sought to undermine BT’s announcement by questioning BT’s calculations that its service is almost £8 per month cheaper. This statement does not hold up because “BT insists on customers having to take phone line from them which costs a further £11.54”, Virgin Media claims. However, Virgin Media’s optional phone line is just £11 per month, meaning that the 40Mb connection is in fact "just £2.47 cheaper” for what Virgin Media dubbed a “much slower service”.

The exchange of words between two of the UK’s largest internet service providers has set the scene for a dogged battle for customers in 10 months time when BT Infinity becomes officially available.

Right now the brickbats flying between the two companies is akin to the so-called phoney war that followed Britain’s declaration of hostilities against Germany in 1939. You can rest assured that relations won’t be this cordial come December when combat really commences.

More news on: Virgin Media, Cable broadband, Future developments, BT broadband

1 comment

  • 1

    Ben, 16th February 2010.

    BT has a lot of catching up to do with Virgin Media, which knows how to market its fibre optic service. Plus I'm not sure BT customer really want a fast connection.

    Reply

Add your comment

Please write a longer comment

Related stories

Top 10 Broadband blog

Our broadband blog is where we discuss the latest broadband news on a range of ‘blogworthy’ broadband topics.

It’s also where our bloggers let users know about interesting developments on our website.